Region Archives: Canada West

Bowinn Ma

North Shuswap resident Kyle Boppre offers a simple explanation when asked why he defied an evacuation order issued as a wildfire bore down on his neighbourhood. “It’s just, I guess, in my blood to fight,” he said. “We were able to save our home.” Boppre and others in the small communities that dot the Shuswap region’s waterfront felt like they were on their own, with no choice but to take the firefight into their own hands. But authorities say that their actions put their lives at risk and imperil firefighting strategies. Emergency Management Minister Bowinn Ma said Wednesday the unwanted presence of evacuation scofflaws could prevent tactics such as water-bombing or controlled burns. …Trent Tucker, a professor at Thompson Rivers University, lost his home to the fires. He said it’s entirely irresponsible for people to stay back in evacuation zones, and he’s “extremely upset” by stories “lionizing” those who defy evacuation orders.

In wake of the most recent wildfire disasters, including the devastation the island of Maui and parts of B.C. continue to experience, it is high time to reflect on an ecological approach to forest management. …Nowhere is that argument clearer than in B.C., where government data shows forest sector emissions generated in the last decade are greater than all industry sectors combined. The province has taken that information one step further, stating in two recent government reports that B.C. must change forest management practices so they support prioritizing ecosystem health and resilience over timber. …Throughout history, priority has been placed on finding opportunities to log the last valuable trees in existence. …The only solution to this new wildfire reality is changing our perspective on forest sector carbon emissions and that starts with putting ecologically driven forest management policies into practice.

Canada’s current wildfire season is devastating evidence of the effects of climate change, scientists say, but for some conspiracy theorists, the thousands of square kilometres of burnt ground isn’t enough to convince them. Instead, space lasers, arsonists and government plots to restrict people’s movement are some of the causes of the fires, according to fringe online circles. …these theories are widely circulated and boosted by social media algorithms. …Kawser Ahmed, professor at University of Winnipeg, said almost all conspiracy theories have a spark of truth but are distorted to attract attention. Forest fires, he said, are spectacular events that draw attention before the full facts come to light, and conspiracy theories fill in the gaps. But such theories harm those who are fleeing the fires and those who are fighting the blazes, he noted. …Kennedy said conspiracy theories can cause diminishing trust among people, which could reduce compliance with evacuation orders.

Wildfires have already burned a hole through the wooden wallets of BC. …It is the practice of the provincial government to focus firefighting efforts on areas where homes and other structures are in danger of burning. In the past, that has meant that parcels held by First Nations for their future financial sustainability over decades have been erased in a matter of a couple of weeks. …“Unfortunately, the active wildfires in the Quesnel and Williams Lake regions are affecting several tenure holders, including a First Nation held tenure by the name of Yun Ka Whu’ten Development Limited Partnership, and Tolko. …The largest forest products manufacturing company in the region, West Fraser Timber, has also been affected. The cultural, ecological and recreational losses are virtually incalculable, as is the amount of greenhouse gases emitted without purpose.

Bruce Blackwell

Fire suppression in the areas where homes touch on wilderness has made tremendous progress since recommendations two decades ago in a seminal report sparked by a devastating wildfire season in B.C., according to experts who contributed to that report. But experts add that much more work is needed on the prevention side to protect communities, another key recommendation of the report, called Firestorm 2003. …Bruce Blackwell, a longtime forestry consultant, said that 20 years ago there was no co-operation and co-ordination between city fire departments that protect structures and the B.C. Wildfire Service. Now their operations are integrated. And he pointed to resources from other city fire departments from all over the province that poured into Kelowna in the past week… “On the suppression side, I would say what’s going on in Kelowna has been exceptional. From that perspective, we’ve certainly made tremendous progress,” said Blackwell, who contributed to the 2003 report.

Bruce Ralston

B.C. Forests Minister Bruce Ralston blamed local governments for slow progress on reducing wildfire risk in-and-around their communities. But experts have said there isn’t enough funding to make substantive progress. …Asked during a wildfire briefing about the slow pace of clearing wildfire fuel in communities where homes touch wilderness areas, Ralston pointed to “well-developed” provincial funding programs to which municipalities and First Nations can apply to carry out the work. They can be the difference between successfully extinguishing a fire and seeing a fire … do profound damage to a community, said Ralston. …Experts put the blame on the province for a lack of progress on fire prevention, saying funding available to communities in no way matches the need. A Postmedia investigation also showed local governments faced obstacles to access funding and an overwhelming bureaucratic process.

Summer 2023’s record Interior blazes are serving as a reminder about the need to spend more to prevent and mitigate wildfires. But the province must also rethink its methods, according to a June report by an independent government and industry watchdog. “Wildfire risk reduction or restoration treatments can be costly, and there is currently little funding to support landscape treatment outside the wildland urban interface,” said the Forest and Fire Management in B.C. report from the Forest Practices Board (FPB). …“If the people of B.C. want to co-exist with fire, there is an urgent need to act now at a pace and scale that will achieve landscape resilience,” the report said. …South of the border, the Biden administration has already turned its attention toward landscape fire management. The 10-year Wildfire Crisis Strategy is part of an US$8.25-billion program to treat 20 million acres.

First Nations say British Columbia’s most destructive wildfire season to date is having devastating impacts on their communities. And not just on physical structures, but on culture and tradition. By July 18 of this year, more than 14,000 square kilometres of land had already burned in B.C., which broke a record of just over 13,500 square kilometres in 2018. One of the most significant fires up to July 18 was the Donnie Creek wildfire, the largest in the province’s history. It was burning — and continues to burn — in northeast B.C., in the traditional territories of the Prophet River First Nation, Doig River First Nation and Blueberry River First Nations. First Nations members say the cultural destruction from the Donnie Creek fire is impossible to quantify, and now similar loss is occurring due to fires burning in the Okanagan, Shuswap and Fraser Canyon.

This year has been the most destructive wildfire season on record in British Columbia. An unprecedented provincial state of emergency has been declared, and communities all over our province are facing evacuation orders and threats of fast-moving wildfires. …Our union is standing with the frontline staff who are working around the clock to keep our communities safe, including the almost 2,000 BCGEU members in the BC Wildfire Service – both those on wildland firefighting crews and the administrative professionals, dispatchers and many others that support their work. …Last week, our union launched an open letter asking Forests Minister Bruce Ralston to increase wages, offer firefighters the same pension as other public safety responders and fix outstanding payroll delays so that these workers can do the work they are so committed to with the resources they need. Now is the time to support wildland firefighters and they need your support!

Andrew Weaver

The summer of 2023 is one for the record books. June and July were the warmest months ever recorded, and extreme temperature records were broken around the world. …And yet, this pales in comparison to what we can expect in the years ahead from ongoing global warming arising from greenhouse gas emissions released through the combustion of fossil fuels. …It appears little has been done to prepare rural Canada for what’s in store as governments deal with immediate, rather than transformational approaches to wildfire management. …Forest management practices including forest fire prevention, monoculture reforestation and the use of glyphosate to kill off broadleaf plant species, will all have to be reassessed from a science- and risk-based perspective. …Canadians will take solace as summer turns into winter and the immediacy of our 2023 wildfire situation wanes. Unfortunately, it will be Australia’s turn next.

Sunshine Coast Community Forest (SCCF) has halted regular meetings with Elphinstone Logging Focus (ELF) because of interpersonal dynamics as planning continues for fall logging of an Angus Creek area cutblock. An alleged statement by ELF spokesperson Ross Muirhead during an Aug. 6 public tour of that cutblock, prompted Hansen to inform ELF of a decision to “discontinue our meetings” earlier this month. …The board directed that additional sessions would not proceed until Terms of Reference to define a common purpose and appropriate participant conduct were agreed to. While that rule development process was under way, Hansen received a report of a statement disrespectful of his professionalism being made during the tour event which, according to ELF, was attended by 40 people. …Muirhead denied making the remarks.

Rachel Holt

Ecologist Dr. Rachel Holt is unwavering in her dedication to what she sees as the vitally important work of conservation. “My work has evolved around changing how we manage the land in BC.” Dr. Holt has been doing this work for over 30 years, mostly for the provincial government and for various First Nations. …So, what are some of the solutions Holt sees as critical? One key step would be to shift from having only six or seven large companies driving how industrial forestry operates, to many more mid-sized companies such as Kalesnikoff [who] provide a much higher ratio of jobs for every tree harvested through the production of value-added forest products. The transition could also include many more community forests …Holt emphasizes that “government has to provide clear direction to BCTS and other forestry companies… What is considered acceptable needs to change.”

…To Megan Einarson, who was arrested in the recent Fairy Creek protests and has returned to join a new group in opposition to old growth logging, it’s difficult to see how many trees have been felled since the protests….The latest group to protest in the injunction area, called Savage Patch, says they are an Indigenous-led movement focused on Indigenous sovereignty and the protection of old growth forests.  On Aug. 15, RCMP arrested three protesters from Savage Patch for breaching a court-ordered injunction after the group blockaded a bridge to prevent logging company Teal Cedar Products from logging in the area. …Leaders from the Pacheedaht First Nation say the protesters do not represent them, and have asked that Savage Patch respect the nation’s rights to manage their territory without interference. …Peter Orlić, a member of Savage Patch, said it’s a misconception that their group is against industry.

The Forest Practices Board has released an investigative report about the management of habitat for species-at-risk under the Forest and Range Practices Act and concludes the B.C. government has work to do. …“Where government sets clear, legal objectives, licensees comply,” said Bruce Larson, vice-chair, Forest Practices Board. “However, the legal tools available to government aren’t always being used and we found a lack of transparency in how government makes decisions about balancing timber supply and habitat protection.” …The board is calling for government to update its policies for managing the habitat of species-at-risk, including increasing transparency and clear direction on the use and timing of available tools under the act, as well as supporting an integrated approach to habitat supply that considers multiple species. 

HIGH PRAIRIE, Alberta — “Since time immemorial” Swan River First Nation (SRFN) has used the land near Lesser Slave Lake, says Dustin Twin. …In the 1990s, Swan River members started having concerns about there being not enough undisturbed land to support members who wanted to practice traditional land-use. …At the same time, Driftpile Cree Nation had land it didn’t want logged. Both Driftpile and Swan River decided to hold culture camps on the area they didn’t want logged. …The culture camps protest started in-depth conversations with West Fraser, which ended with the understanding the area was “a complete no go,” says Twin. “It’s progressed quite a ways.” The preserve falls within the portfolio of Todd Bailey, SRFN director of forestry consultation. Swan River is “planning for seven generations,” and “intact areas is an important part of that.”